This is a song about a marriage proposal. "Someday somebody's gonna ask you, a question that you should say 'yes' to once in your life. Maybe tonight I've got a question for you." I put this song on the second mix-tape I made for my wife (the first one I made for her after we were engaged.) The song was also used in an episode of Scrubs, where Turk proposes to Carla.
Aside from being a wonderfully sappy, romantic song, there are three topics this song brings up that I feel I must discuss:
1) Lead singers of groups who also have solo careers
Rhett Miller is the lead singer of the group the Old 97s. (They were featured on this list way back at #176 with the song "Murder or a Heart Attack.") I think I have four Old 97s albums (two of which I really like) and two solo albums by lead singer Rhett Miller (both of which I like.)
But, neither the lead singer nor the group ever got famous enough for it to be a "Rhett Miller and the Old 97s" situation like it did with "Sting and the Police," "Phil Collins and Genesis," "Lionel Richie and the Commodores," "George Michael and WHAM!," or "Peaches and Herb." Because that's always awkward.
2) When it comes to song remakes, I always like the version I heard first. (Except this time.)
When there is more than one version of a song, I almost always like the version I heard first. The Move (predecessors of ELO) had a version of "Do Ya," but I heard the ELO version first, and I prefer it. I generally don't like "live" recordings, but I prefer every song from Billy Joel's "Songs In the Attic" live recordings to the original versions, partly because I heard the live versions first. And, I don't care how many octaves she can sing, but Mariah Carey can't come close to Harry Nilsson's version of "Without You."
How big of an impact do those first impressions make? Well, generally speaking I love the Beatles and loathe Aerosmith. (The only way Steven Tyler could try to be more like Mick Jagger would be if he actually changed his name to "Mick Jagger.") And yet to this day I still kinda prefer Aerosmith's version of "Come Together" over the original take by the Beatles. And that's because I heard Aerosmith's version first.
This song is the exception to the rule. The song first appeared on the Old 97s album "Satellite Rides." I really liked it. Then a few years later a slightly different version popped up on Rhett Miller's solo album "The Believer." Both versions are sung by Miller, but the newer "solo" version adds 42 seconds (mostly a repeat of the chorus) and is slightly sappier. And I like it better.
C) Album cover that lack creativity
Rhett Miller suffers from "Phil Collins Syndrome."
Album covers can be amazing. There are so many fun and wonderful things that can be done with an album cover. You could put a space ship on it. You could put a futuristic landscape, a beautiful painting, or an interesting photograph on it. You could put a beautiful woman on it. You could put a beautiful woman covered in whipped cream on it. (Thanks, Herb Alpert!) You could even have a bunch of guys pointing at their belly buttons on it (though I wouldn't recommend that.)
Or, you could have Phil Collins Syndrome: "You know what would be great for this album cover? A big, close-up picture of my face! Yup, that's what everyone wants to see!"
For his first solo album, "The Instigator," Rhett Miller went with the Phil Collins approach. Here is the result:
![]() |
Hi. I'm Rhett Miller. This is a close-up picture of my face. |
![]() |
So many faces!!! |
Just to be clear, each one of these three extra Rhett Miller faces is as large as the picture on the front cover, so if you fold the cd booklet out, accordion-style, you get four huge, close-up pictures of Rhett Miller's face!
Rhett Miller wants you to look at his face! Look at it!!! LOOK AT IT!!!!!
(It's a good thing his songs are so good.)
COMING UP NEXT: Start me up!